Student Leroy

A gay student's struggle: 'I am in an incredibly dangerous situation'

For a homosexual student from Eritrea, his arrival in the Netherlands was not just a choice of study, but primarily an escape. Because he can no longer afford to pay for his studies, he now risks returning to his home country, where homosexuality is punishable. He fears total isolation as well as his safety. There are more students in this situation, says Marco Strijks, who is advocating for the student. Solutions are being worked on in the background.

The first thing Leroy* looked up on google when he chose a new study abroad program? "I literally searched 'safest countries for homosexuals,'" he says. He himself knew at a young age that he was attracted to men. "Although I didn't even have a word for it at the time."

In high school, others started calling him gay. "Then I started researching, and I thought, oh okay, a lot makes sense now." In Eritrea, he says, homosexuals are completely excluded from society. "That goes so far that they wouldn't serve me in the store if they knew I was gay. They would disgrace me, pretend I don't exist."

Homosexuality is also illegal by law in Eritrea: previously, sexual acts with someone of the same sex were punishable by 3 years in prison. In the country's new criminal law, it is as much as five to seven years.

LGBTQI+rights in Eritrea

A 2022 official report by the Dutch Ministry of Foreign Affairs endorses Leroy's story of exclusion: it states in black and white that Eritrea has a very conservative society. In the collective perception, gay, bisexual and transgender people are possessed by demons. The danger of punishment, the negative reaction from family and society, which are the only social safety net in Eritrea, are so great in Eritrea that lhbti persons keep themselves hidden or live in denial. The pressure is so great on this group, the ministry writes, that information about this group can hardly be found.

The U.S. State Department also writes in a human rights report about the rights of LGBTQI+ in Eritrea. According to the Americans, same-sex sex is not only punishable in the country, the government actively applies that law. Little is known about violence: repression is so great that people from the LGBTQI+ community in Eritrea are afraid to speak out: they are too afraid of the social repercussions and discrimination if their identity becomes known.

Leroy himself says that as a high school student, this is why he had to put on a mask. To an extreme degree. "I couldn't be myself. I behaved completely different than I am, agreed with everyone for example. Even with people I didn't agree with at all. I did everything not to deviate from the rest."

Hiding who he was had major socio-emotional consequences. He struggled with persistent suicidal thoughts, he says. "Mentally, I was in the worst possible place. Still, I wanted to see how things could be different before I ended it."

He began forging a plan for the future. That led to that Internet search, where Holland came out as an option. "I was looking for a place where I had the freedom to be myself. Where I didn't have to put on a mask and could live my own life."

That place eventually became Saxion, specifically the Creative Media and Game Technologies (CMGT) degree program. The study - and the place - were everything he had hoped for, and actually much more. 

Choosing CMGT, Saxion and joining study association XP was the best decision of his life, he says. "This was really the best thing I could ever do. The community of this study feels like a family. It really is the safest place I could have wished for, a large group of originally introverted people who feel so safe together that they suddenly become extroverts."

For the first time in his life Leroy crawled out of his shell, entered into relationships, made real contact, he says. And he felt safe. Until this year. For Leroy's family stopped transferring his tuition. And that has major consequences.

DSCF6270.jpg

Leroy* literally searched "safest countries for homosexuals" before deciding to study at Saxion. Photos: Marlene Mahn

Tuition

At first Leroy thought this was because his family suspects what his sexual orientation is. Although that is not expressed; the shame and risk of social exclusion, including for the family, is too great for that.

Later, he found out the real reason: through contact with a family member, he discovered that his family is struggling financially and simply can no longer afford to pay for his studies, although he says they will never say that out of shame. "In Eritrea, it's very important to keep up appearances," he says.

So Leroy is in deep trouble: he can no longer afford his tuition. As a student from a country outside the European Union, he pays the institutional fee. At Saxion, that fee is now set at 8,600 euros a year. He cannot afford this himself. A foreign student is allowed to work a maximum of 16 hours per week in the Netherlands.

Those who do not pay their tuition fees will eventually be disenrolled. For Leroy, this not only means that he cannot finish his studies. For him, it means that he would lose his residence permit. That is tied to his status as a student.

Emergency Fund

Through contacts with a student counsellor , Leroy is now making every effort to obtain additional resources through funds. For this year, he succeeded. Sort of. Saxion actually has an emergency fund, for students who can no longer pay their tuition. Leroy was told this month that he can appeal to the fund for this academic year. But it's not easy: it's a loan, and the money must be repaid in installments before September. "It's really an emergency loan, whereas my problem is permanent," he said.

He is saved for this year, although he is left with a hefty loan, the question of how he will pay it back remains. Moreover, he is not out of the woods: for next academic year there is still no solution for him and he still has to get the institutional tuition of 8,600 euros a year from somewhere.

Leroy is in talks with the director of his academy ACT. "Maybe something will come out of that," he said. Director Arjan Zemann says that this is a personal situation and therefore it is difficult for him to comment on the case. "What I can say is that we are having a very good conversation with this student and trying to help him in many ways." And for Leroy, encouragingly, "We are confident that this is going to work out."

Should all else fail, there is one last, for Leroy very last option. He could apply for refugee status, but that has major implications. He would no longer be able to work, for example. He would, however, possibly be entitled to lower tuition. He would also then have to move out of his current home, Leroy says. And he would cut off all his ties to his home country, family and acquaintances in Eritrea. "Everything I have now, I would then have to give up. But it is an option, as the very very last way out."

He is afraid. Very afraid, he says. "I'm in an incredibly dangerous situation. It feels like I'm standing on thin, cracking ice." So now he tells this story. Despite the potential risks it poses to him and his family. In fact, there is also another, bigger motive for telling his story, he says. A reason that is very important to him. He is not the only one in this situation, he thinks. "There are others as well. Those I think feel very alone. I want them to know that they are not the only ones."

*Leroy is not this student's real name. His real name is known to the (chief) editors, but in this case we chose to make it anonymous, in order to minimize the security risk. In consultation with Leroy, we do mention his studies; he himself would like that. "I think it's important for my story."

This article briefly discusses suicide. Do you need help? Then you can contact the 113 Suicide Prevention Foundation at 0900-0113 (available 24/7) and 113.nl.

Marco Strijks: "Letting him go back is equivalent to killing him

The government should have a safety net for cases like this, says Marco Strijks, Saxion lecturer and ambassador of Th!nk with Pride. According to him, there are more students like Leroy: students who see their lives here more as an escape than just a study.

He knows at least one other example. A student in transition who studied at UT, but now lives in Amsterdam and has applied for refugee status. "She only doesn't want to share her story, I think she's afraid of recognition," he says.

According to him, there is currently no agency or foundation that helps students like Leroy. Letting Leroy go back to Eritrea is not an option for him. "We can't let this boy go back. If he gets beaten up there, there is no one to help him. He will be killed there, or maybe hurt himself."

Student counsellor: "Academy is looking for a solution"

As student counsellor, Marle Groote Schaarsberg has been involved in Leroy's situation for some time. Together with him, for example, she is looking for facilities to which he can appeal. Within Saxion, according to her, there is only one facility he can appeal to: the emergency facility. "That has just now been granted to him, but that money must be repaid before the end of August."

She is in a bind, she says. Saxion is bound by regulations, making an exception for Leroy very difficult. After all, that has precedent, she says. "And who do you make an exception for and who don't?"

She says she runs up against her limits a bit. "After all, this is a student I do care very much about." So she is looking for outside funds, and also put Leroy in touch with the academy director of his program. "From there, a solution is being sought," she said. 

IND: No numbers of comparable cases

If someone from outside the EU loses their educational registration, their residence permit expires, Immigration and Naturalization Service (IND) spokesperson Cilya van der Kooij informs. The service then sends a return decision. The person in question must then leave the Netherlands within four weeks. 

The Immigration and Naturalization Service (IND) will not comment on whether Leroy qualifies for refugee status. However, the service does reveal that there is no specific country policy for LGBT people from Eritrea. Refugees and asylum seekers may continue to study while applying for asylum. The IND says it does not keep figures of comparable cases. "This is recorded in individual files."

Bas3

Bas Klaassen